Megan Martin: Medicaid reforms protect taxpayers and empower beneficiaries

Posted

These days, everyone is talking about the election results and their aftermath. Here in Pennsylvania, the focus is on the Democrat trifecta and what comes next. One thing coming — but with much wailing and teeth-gnashing from Democrats — are critical changes to Medicaid. Despite what the press routinely portrays as cruel cuts, these changes will help more Americans regain their independence. This freedom should be celebrated, not vilified by political partisans.

Starting in 2027, part-time work requirements for some Medicaid recipients go into effect. Able-bodied adults between 19 and 64 years old with no kids — namely, those who enrolled with the Obamacare expansion — must complete 80 hours per month of paid employment, volunteering, job training, or a combination. That amounts to 20 hours per week — no more than a part-time commitment. Importantly, Medicaid’s original targeted demographics (i.e., kids, people with disabilities, and the elderly) are exempt from the new work requirements.

These requirements restore the dignity of work and independence and preserve the services for those truly in need. Arkansas, which implemented work requirements well before the new federal requirements, saw a spike in employment among Medicaid beneficiaries. More than 14,000 also reported higher incomes, which helped them become less dependent on government assistance.

Simply put, work requirements work. They provide a reasonable accountability tool that protects funds for the most vulnerable and needy.

And accountability has never been more necessary. Waste, fraud, and abuse of Medicaid benefits have become a nationwide epidemic. Nationally, the U.S. Government Accountability Office reported $186 billion in improper payments (most of which were overpayments) in 2025, a $24 billion increase from the previous year.

Cautionary tales keep popping up nationwide. In Louisiana, an audit found that 82 of 100 expansion enrollees exceeded the income limit. Meanwhile, in Minnesota, federal investigators have uncovered case after case after case of multimillion-dollar fraud schemes.

Pennsylvania isn’t immune, either. Between 2024 and 2025, fraud cases in the commonwealth more than doubled, increasing by 165 percent. Last year, the commonwealth ranked first nationally in Medicaid fraud convictions, with 115 convictions and more than $41 million recovered.

But finding and convicting fraud only scratches the surface. The damage is already done, and it costs taxpayers extra to investigate, prosecute, and convict fraudsters. Plus, the millions recovered from fraud cases pale in comparison to the larger estimates of detected waste, fraud, and abuse. Even Gov. Josh Shapiro, back when he served as attorney general, estimated that Pennsylvanians lose about $3 billion per year to fraud. This discrepancy suggests a much larger systemic problem.

Enforcement is all well and good, and our Attorney General must continue to vigorously prosecute the fraudsters.

But prevention is a moral imperative. Pennsylvania should conduct regular eligibility and provider audits to identify problems before they become expensive. This means empowering the state’s auditor general to conduct annual audits, focusing specifically on providers since they seem to be the most persistent source of fraud.

In 2027, the federal government will require Pennsylvania to perform eligibility redeterminations every six months for healthy adults to identify more improper payments. Some, such as Indiana and New Hampshire, are already planning to verify quarterly.

These eligibility reforms are essential because Pennsylvania pays beneficiaries monthly. If someone dies, the commonwealth continues to pay every month until the provider corrects the status. If someone earns above the income limit, Pennsylvania pays every month until that is reconciled. The good people of our great Commonwealth deserve to have their hard-earned tax dollars safeguarded and spent wisely, not frivolously spent maintaining a fraudulent and error-filled government program.

Pennsylvanians are receptive to these reforms. A Commonwealth Foundation poll found that 77 percent support work requirements for healthy adults receiving welfare benefits, with exemptions for seniors, people with disabilities, and adults with kids. Another 77 percent support more frequent eligibility checks and regular audits to prevent waste, fraud, and abuse.

Increased oversight is necessary considering the program’s enormous financial commitment of taxpayer dollars. Medicaid accounts for nearly half of state spending. And with growing concerns about the commonwealth’s structural deficit ($4.7 billion this fiscal year, according to the Independent Fiscal Office) and possible statewide tax hikes, Pennsylvanians literally cannot afford to ignore this issue any longer.

The Shapiro administration has a responsibility to provide medical care for the most vulnerable, reduce improper payments, and make it more difficult to cheat taxpayers. Pennsylvania can — and should — protect the vulnerable by reducing eligibility mistakes, holding providers accountable, and encouraging work.

Pennsylvania doesn’t have to choose between a safety net and widespread wasteful spending. Protecting the vulnerable and respecting taxpayers are the same goal, and Pennsylvania should start pursuing it now. The good people of our great Commonwealth deserve no less.

Megan Martin is the chief operating officer and general counsel for the Commonwealth Foundation, Pennsylvania’s free-market think tank.

Opinion, Government Spending, Health, health care, Medicaid, Welfare, Work